| | | Utica won toss and elects to receive |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes30 | WILKES ball on WILKES30. |
| | | Chris Horn kickoff 64 yards to the UTICA6, Jeremy Meier return 17 yards to the UTICA23 (Andrew Carbone). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica23 | Jake Scott rush for 3 yards to the UTICA26 (Walt Pabst). |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Utica26 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tim Millerick for 5 yards to the UTICA31 (Shane Stanek). |
| Utica | 3-2 | at Utica31 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete (Chris Swinarski). |
| Utica | 4-2 | at Utica31 | Donato Pinnisi punt 43 yards to the WILKES26, downed. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:40 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes26 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 13:20. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes26 | Tyler Berntsen pass complete to Zach Tivald for loss of 1 yard to the WILKES25 (Marquez Mosely;T. Cunningham). |
| Wilkes | 2-11 | at Wilkes25 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to Jordan D'Emilio (Kevin Hennion). |
| Wilkes | 3-11 | at Wilkes25 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 7 yards to the WILKES32 (Travis Ladd). |
| Wilkes | 4-4 | at Wilkes32 | Chris Horn punt 45 yards to the UTICA23, Joshua Mason return 8 yards to the UTICA31 (Harry Reese;Walt Pabst). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 6 yards, TOP 01:32 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica31 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 11:48. |
| | | TV Time out |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica31 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Anthony Acevedo for 5 yards to the UTICA36 (V. Trentacost;Harry Reese). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Utica36 | Jake Scott rush for 5 yards to the UTICA41, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Walt Pabst;Shane Stanek). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica41 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 3 yards to the UTICA44 (Kevin Gerhart;Ryan Clifford). |
| Utica | 2-7 | at Utica44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jake Scott for 4 yards to the UTICA48 (Shane Stanek;Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Utica48 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Jeremy Meier. |
| Utica | 4-3 | at Utica48 | Donato Pinnisi punt 34 yards to the WILKES18, fair catch by Jordan D'Emilio. |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards, TOP 02:27 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes18 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:21. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes18 | Zach Tivald rush for 7 yards to the WILKES25 (Travis Ladd). |
| Wilkes | 2-3 | at Wilkes25 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 2 yards to the WILKES27 (Kevin Hennion;Tracy Branch). |
| Wilkes | 3-1 | at Wilkes27 | Zach Tivald rush for 3 yards to the WILKES30, 1ST DOWN WILKES (Jerrod Clowes;Kevin Hennion). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes30 | 1st and 10. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes30 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 5 yards to the WILKES35 (Genaro Scampone;Travis Ladd). |
| Wilkes | 2-5 | at Wilkes35 | Tyler Berntsen pass complete to Jordan D'Emilio for 7 yards to the WILKES42, 1ST DOWN WILKES (Jonathan White;Genaro Scampone). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes42 | Zach Tivald rush for 9 yards to the UTICA49 (Travis Ladd;T. Cunningham). |
| Wilkes | 2-1 | at Utica49 | Tyler Berntsen pass complete to Jordan D'Emilio for 1 yard to the UTICA48, 1ST DOWN WILKES (Kody Parkhurst). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica48 | PENALTY UTICA pass interference 10 yards to the UTICA38, 1ST DOWN WILKES. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica38 | Tyler Berntsen rush for loss of 2 yards to the UTICA40 (Tracy Branch). |
| Wilkes | 2-12 | at Utica40 | Zach Tivald rush for 3 yards to the UTICA37 (Marquez Mosely;Cody Adams). |
| Wilkes | 3-9 | at Utica37 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to Jordan D'Emilio (Kody Parkhurst). |
| Wilkes | 4-9 | at Utica37 | Chris Horn punt 26 yards to the UTICA11, fair catch by R. Alexander. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 45 yards, TOP 04:42 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica11 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 04:39. |
| | | TV Time out |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica11 | Jake Scott rush for 5 yards to the UTICA16 (Tate Moore-Jaco;Harry Reese). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Utica16 | Jake Scott rush for loss of 5 yards to the UTICA11 (Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Utica11 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 18 yards to the UTICA29, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kevin Gerhart;Greg Nielsen). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica29 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 15 yards to the UTICA44, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Shane Stanek). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason (Joe Chrismer). |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Utica44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Jake Scott. |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Utica44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Zachary Jensen for 10 yards to the WILKES46, 1ST DOWN UTICA. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes46 | Jake Scott rush for loss of 1 yard to the WILKES47 (Chris Swinarski;Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 2-11 | at Wilkes47 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Anthony Acevedo for 5 yards to the WILKES42 (Shane Stanek). |
| Utica | 3-6 | at Wilkes42 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Anthony Acevedo. |
| Utica | 4-6 | at Wilkes42 | Donato Pinnisi punt 29 yards to the WILKES13, fair catch by Jordan D'Emilio. |
| | | Drive: 10 plays, 47 yards, TOP 03:52 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes13 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 00:47. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes13 | Zach Tivald rush for 6 yards to the WILKES19 (Genaro Scampone). |
| Wilkes | 2-4 | at Wilkes19 | Marc Persing pass incomplete to Anthony Dorunda (Genaro Scampone). |
| Wilkes | 3-4 | at Wilkes19 | Marc Persing pass complete to Zach Tivald for 9 yards to the WILKES28, 1ST DOWN WILKES (Michael Clark). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 15 yards, TOP 02:20 |
| | | Wilkes University 0, Utica College 0 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes28 | Start of 2nd quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes28 | Auxence Wogou rush for 2 yards to the WILKES30 (Travis Ladd;Kevin Hennion). |
| Wilkes | 2-8 | at Wilkes30 | Marc Persing pass incomplete to Jordan D'Emilio (Travis Ladd). |
| Wilkes | 3-8 | at Wilkes30 | Marc Persing sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WILKES24 (James Brain), fumble by Marc Persing recovered by WILKES Brendon Myer at WILKES24. |
| Wilkes | 4-14 | at Wilkes24 | Chris Horn punt 22 yards to the WILKES46, downed. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 11 yards, TOP 02:20 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes46 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 13:27. |
| | | TV Timeout |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes46 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Tim Millerick. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Wilkes46 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tim Millerick for 20 yards to the WILKES26, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Greg Nielsen). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes26 | Jake Scott rush for loss of 2 yards to the WILKES28. |
| Utica | 2-12 | at Wilkes28 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 17 yards to the WILKES11, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kevin Gerhart;Greg Nielsen). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes11 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 11 yards to the WILKES0, 1ST DOWN UTICA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 11:37. |
| | | TJ Losowski kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica College 7, Wilkes University 0 |
| | | TV Timeout |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 46 yards, TOP 01:56 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 64 yards to the WILKES6, Parrish Fells return 25 yards to the WILKES31 (William Northey). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes31 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 11:31. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes31 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 6 yards to the WILKES37 (Kody Parkhurst). |
| Wilkes | 2-4 | at Wilkes37 | Tyler Berntsen pass complete to Anthony Dorunda for 3 yards to the WILKES40 (Marquez Mosely). |
| Wilkes | 3-1 | at Wilkes40 | Zach Tivald rush for no gain to the WILKES40 (M. Herberger). |
| Wilkes | 4-1 | at Wilkes40 | Chris Horn punt 28 yards to the UTICA32, Joshua Mason return 0 yards to the UTICA32, fumble by Joshua Mason recovered by WILKES TEAM at UTICA24, PENALTY UTICA personal foul 15 yards to the UTICA9, 1st and 10, WILKES ball on UTICA9. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 9 yards, TOP 01:55 |
| Wilkes | 1-G | at Utica09 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:36. |
| Wilkes | 1-G | at Utica09 | Zach Tivald rush for 9 yards to the UTICA0, TOUCHDOWN, clock 09:22. |
| | | Chris Horn kick attempt good. |
| | | Wilkes University 7, Utica College 7 |
| | | #4 for Utica ejected for throwing a punch |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 9 yards, TOP 00:20 |
| | | Chris Horn kickoff 55 yards to the UTICA15, Jeremy Meier return 11 yards to the UTICA26 (Duanne Daniels). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica26 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 09:16. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica26 | Andrew Benkwitt pass intercepted by Kyle Regensburg at the UTICA43, Kyle Regensburg return 0 yards to the UTICA43 (Joshua Mason). |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:06 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica43 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:10. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica43 | Zach Tivald rush for 7 yards to the UTICA36 (Kevin Hennion). |
| Wilkes | 2-3 | at Utica36 | Zach Tivald rush for 6 yards to the UTICA30, 1ST DOWN WILKES (Travis Ladd;T. Cunningham). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica30 | Zach Tivald rush for 5 yards to the UTICA25 (Jonathan White;Genaro Scampone). |
| Wilkes | 2-5 | at Utica25 | Zach Tivald rush for 1 yard to the UTICA24 (T. Cunningham). |
| Wilkes | 3-4 | at Utica24 | Marc Persing pass incomplete. |
| Wilkes | 4-4 | at Utica24 | Chris Horn field goal attempt from 41 MISSED - wide left, spot at UTICA24, clock 06:57. |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 19 yards, TOP 08:59 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica24 | Jake Scott rush for 9 yards to the UTICA33 (Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 2-1 | at Utica33 | Jake Scott rush for 5 yards to the UTICA38, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kyle Regensburg). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica38 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Anthony Acevedo for 14 yards to the WILKES48, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes48 | Timeout Utica College, clock 05:25. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes48 | Jake Scott rush for 2 yards to the WILKES46 (Kevin Gerhart;Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Wilkes46 | Jake Scott rush for 7 yards to the WILKES39 (Shane Stanek;Harry Reese). |
| | | Wilkes #41 Injured on the play |
| Utica | 3-1 | at Wilkes39 | Jake Scott rush for 1 yard to the WILKES38, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes38 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tim Millerick for 7 yards to the WILKES31 (Ryan Clifford;Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 2-3 | at Wilkes31 | Jake Scott rush for 6 yards to the WILKES25, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Greg Nielsen;Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes25 | PENALTY UTICA false start (Matt Dunn) 5 yards to the WILKES30. |
| Utica | 1-15 | at Wilkes30 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Tim Millerick for 3 yards to the WILKES27 (Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 2-12 | at Wilkes27 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WILKES33 (Tate Moore-Jaco;Ryan Clifford). |
| Utica | 3-18 | at Wilkes33 | PENALTY UTICA false start (Jeremy Meier) 5 yards to the WILKES38. |
| Utica | 3-23 | at Wilkes38 | Timeout Wilkes University, clock 00:56. |
| Utica | 3-23 | at Wilkes38 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 6 yards to the WILKES44 (Ryan Clifford;Chris Swinarski). |
| Utica | 4-29 | at Wilkes44 | Timeout Wilkes University, clock 00:20. |
| Utica | 4-29 | at Wilkes44 | Donato Pinnisi punt 43 yards to the WILKES1, downed. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 32 yards, TOP 00:00 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes01 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 00:11. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes01 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 1 yard to the WILKES2 (Adam Luczak). |
| Wilkes | 2-9 | at Wilkes02 | End of half, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | Wilkes University 7, Utica College 7 |
| Wilkes | 2-9 | at Wilkes02 | Start of 3rd quarter, clock 15:00, UTICA ball on UTICA30. |
| | | Drive: 1 plays, 1 yards, TOP 00:11 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 53 yards to the WILKES17, Parrish Fells return 4 yards to the WILKES21 (B. Wallace;Luke Manolescu). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes21 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 14:53. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes21 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 6 yards to the WILKES27 (T. Cunningham). |
| Wilkes | 2-4 | at Wilkes27 | Zach Tivald rush for 6 yards to the WILKES33, 1ST DOWN WILKES (Cody Adams). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes33 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to Zach Tivald. |
| Wilkes | 2-10 | at Wilkes33 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to David Kratzer (Jonathan White). |
| Wilkes | 3-10 | at Wilkes33 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to Anthony Dorunda. |
| Wilkes | 4-10 | at Wilkes33 | Chris Horn punt 32 yards to the UTICA35, R. Alexander return 4 yards to the UTICA39 (Joe Chrismer;Kyle Rountree). |
| | | Drive: 5 plays, 12 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica39 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 13:38. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica39 | Jake Scott rush for 5 yards to the UTICA44 (Kevin Gerhart;V. Trentacost). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Utica44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Anthony Acevedo (Joe Chrismer). |
| Utica | 3-5 | at Utica44 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 13 yards to the WILKES43 (Seth Fetterolf), PENALTY UTICA illegal formation 5 yards to the UTICA39, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Utica39 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Matt Dunn for 21 yards to the WILKES40, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes40 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 7 yards to the WILKES33 (Harry Reese). |
| Utica | 2-3 | at Wilkes33 | Jake Scott rush for 10 yards to the WILKES23, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Tate Moore-Jaco;Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes23 | Jake Scott rush for 2 yards to the WILKES21 (V. Trentacost;Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Wilkes21 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jake Scott for 2 yards to the WILKES19 (Greg Nielsen). |
| Utica | 3-6 | at Wilkes19 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Jake Scott. |
| Utica | 4-6 | at Wilkes19 | TJ Losowski field goal attempt from 36 GOOD, clock 09:36. |
| | | Utica College 10, Wilkes University 7 |
| | | TV Timeout |
| | | Drive: 9 plays, 42 yards, TOP 04:10 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 67 yards to the WILKES3, Auxence Wogou return 14 yards to the WILKES17 (Jeff Zellner). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes17 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:28. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes17 | Tyler Berntsen rush for 3 yards to the WILKES20 (Cody Adams). |
| Wilkes | 2-7 | at Wilkes20 | Zach Tivald rush for loss of 1 yard to the WILKES19 (Genaro Scampone). |
| Wilkes | 3-8 | at Wilkes19 | Tyler Berntsen pass complete to Jordan D'Emilio for 12 yards to the WILKES31, 1ST DOWN WILKES. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes31 | Zach Tivald rush for 1 yard to the WILKES32 (Tracy Branch;Kevin Hennion). |
| Wilkes | 2-9 | at Wilkes32 | Tyler Berntsen rush for no gain to the WILKES32 (Genaro Scampone). |
| Wilkes | 3-9 | at Wilkes32 | Tyler Berntsen sacked for loss of 5 yards to the WILKES27 (Tracy Branch). |
| Wilkes | 4-14 | at Wilkes27 | Chris Horn punt 12 yards to the WILKES39, out-of-bounds (blocked by Zachary Jones). |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 10 yards, TOP 03:39 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes39 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 05:49. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes39 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Matt Dunn for 9 yards to the WILKES30 (Ryan Clifford). |
| Utica | 2-1 | at Wilkes30 | Justin Becker rush for 5 yards to the WILKES25 (V. Trentacost), PENALTY UTICA holding 10 yards to the WILKES40, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 2-11 | at Wilkes40 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Joshua Mason for 17 yards to the WILKES23, 1ST DOWN UTICA (V. Trentacost;Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes23 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Anthony Acevedo for 10 yards to the WILKES13, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Tate Moore-Jaco;Mark Senchak). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes13 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Anthony Acevedo. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Wilkes13 | Justin Becker rush for 4 yards to the WILKES9 (Walt Pabst;Shane Stanek), PENALTY UTICA holding 5 yards to the WILKES14. |
| Utica | 2-11 | at Wilkes14 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Jeremy Meier for 14 yards to the WILKES0, 1ST DOWN UTICA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 03:00. |
| Utica | 1-G | at Wilkes03 | PENALTY UTICA false start 5 yards to the WILKES8. |
| | | TJ Losowski kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica College 17, Wilkes University 7 |
| | | Drive: 6 plays, 39 yards, TOP 02:57 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 59 yards to the WILKES11, Auxence Wogou return 5 yards to the WILKES16 (Luke Manolescu;William Northey). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes16 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 02:52. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes16 | Marc Persing pass incomplete to Anthony Dorunda. |
| Wilkes | 2-10 | at Wilkes16 | Marc Persing pass incomplete. |
| Wilkes | 3-10 | at Wilkes16 | Marc Persing pass intercepted by Jonathan White at the WILKES44, Jonathan White return 4 yards to the WILKES40 (Jordan D'Emilio). |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 0 yards, TOP 00:21 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes40 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 02:31. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes40 | Justin Becker rush for 20 yards to the WILKES20, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Shane Stanek). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes20 | Justin Becker rush for loss of 2 yards to the WILKES22, fumble by Justin Becker recovered by UTICA Justin Becker at WILKES22. |
| Utica | 2-12 | at Wilkes22 | Andrew Benkwitt pass complete to Matt Dunn for 22 yards to the WILKES0, 1ST DOWN UTICA, TOUCHDOWN, clock 01:13. |
| | | TJ Losowski kick attempt good. |
| | | Utica College 24, Wilkes University 7 |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 40 yards, TOP 01:24 |
| | | TJ Losowski kickoff 68 yards to the WILKES2, David Kratzer return 24 yards to the WILKES26 (R. Alexander). |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes26 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 01:07. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes26 | Zach Tivald rush for 4 yards to the WILKES30 (Jerrod Clowes). |
| Wilkes | 2-6 | at Wilkes30 | Zach Tivald rush for 4 yards to the WILKES34 (Genaro Scampone;Adam Luczak). |
| Wilkes | 3-2 | at Wilkes34 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to Jordan D'Emilio. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:19 |
| | | Utica College 24, Wilkes University 7 |
| Wilkes | 4-2 | at Wilkes34 | Start of 4th quarter, clock 15:00. |
| Wilkes | 4-2 | at Wilkes34 | Chris Horn punt 50 yards to the UTICA16, Joshua Mason return -1 yards to the UTICA15 (Zach Tivald), PENALTY UTICA illegal block 8 yards to the UTICA7, 1st and 10, UTICA ball on UTICA7. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 8 yards, TOP 01:19 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica07 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 14:48. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica07 | PENALTY UTICA false start (Matt Dunn) 4 yards to the UTICA3. |
| Utica | 1-14 | at Utica03 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason. |
| Utica | 2-14 | at Utica03 | Justin Becker rush for 13 yards to the UTICA16 (Kevin Gerhart;Joe Chrismer). |
| Utica | 3-1 | at Utica16 | Justin Becker rush for 6 yards to the UTICA22, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Tate Moore-Jaco;Josh Brito). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica22 | Justin Becker rush for 8 yards to the UTICA30 (Will Jones). |
| Utica | 2-2 | at Utica30 | Justin Becker rush for 17 yards to the UTICA47, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Ryan Clifford;Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | Justin Becker rush for 5 yards to the WILKES48 (Kevin Gerhart;Walt Pabst). |
| Utica | 2-5 | at Wilkes48 | Jake Scott rush for 6 yards to the WILKES42, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Ryan Clifford;Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes42 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 4 yards to the WILKES46 (Shawn Leslie;Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 2-14 | at Wilkes46 | Jake Scott rush for 11 yards to the WILKES35 (Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Wilkes35 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Tyler Malagisi. |
| Utica | 4-3 | at Wilkes35 | Andrew Benkwitt pass incomplete to Joshua Mason. |
| | | Drive: 11 plays, 58 yards, TOP 05:24 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes35 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 09:24. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Wilkes35 | Tyler Berntsen pass complete to David Kratzer for 5 yards to the WILKES40 (Jonathan White). |
| Wilkes | 2-5 | at Wilkes40 | Zach Tivald rush for no gain to the WILKES40 (Tracy Branch;Jerrod Clowes). |
| Wilkes | 3-5 | at Wilkes40 | Tyler Berntsen pass incomplete to Zach Tivald. |
| Wilkes | 4-5 | at Wilkes40 | Chris Horn punt 37 yards to the UTICA23, out-of-bounds. |
| | | Drive: 3 plays, 5 yards, TOP 01:21 |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica23 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 08:03. |
| | | #30 for Wilkes Injured |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica23 | Justin Becker rush for 24 yards to the UTICA47, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Greg Nielsen;Shane Stanek). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica47 | Jake Scott rush for 2 yards to the UTICA49 (Kevin Gerhart;Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 2-8 | at Utica49 | Jake Scott rush for loss of 2 yards to the UTICA47 (Kevin Gerhart;Ryan Clifford). |
| Utica | 3-10 | at Utica47 | Andrew Benkwitt sacked for loss of 10 yards to the UTICA37 (Rob Houseknecht). |
| Utica | 4-20 | at Utica37 | Timeout Wilkes University, clock 05:47. |
| Utica | 4-20 | at Utica37 | Donato Pinnisi punt BLOCKED, recovered by WILKES Aashon Blackwel at UTICA23 (blocked by Alex George). |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 14 yards, TOP 02:25 |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica23 | WILKES UNIVERSITY drive start at 05:38. |
| Wilkes | 1-10 | at Utica23 | Marc Persing pass complete to Jordan D'Emilio for 2 yards to the UTICA21 (;Kevin Hennion). |
| Wilkes | 2-8 | at Utica21 | PENALTY WILKES false start 4 yards to the UTICA25. |
| Wilkes | 2-12 | at Utica25 | Marc Persing pass incomplete to Jon Kocher. |
| Wilkes | 3-12 | at Utica25 | Marc Persing pass complete to David Kratzer for 3 yards to the UTICA22. |
| Wilkes | 4-9 | at Utica22 | Chris Horn field goal attempt from 39 GOOD, clock 04:28. |
| | | Utica College 24, Wilkes University 10 |
| | | Drive: 4 plays, 1 yards, TOP 01:15 |
| | | Chris Horn kickoff 60 yards to the UTICA10, Andy Moth return 21 yards to the UTICA31 (Mike Maresca). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica31 | UTICA COLLEGE drive start at 04:23. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica31 | Jake Scott rush for 6 yards to the UTICA37 (Harry Reese;Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 2-4 | at Utica37 | Jake Scott rush for 1 yard to the UTICA38 (Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 3-3 | at Utica38 | Jake Scott rush for no gain to the UTICA38 (V. Trentacost;Harry Reese), PENALTY WILKES offside defense 5 yards to the UTICA43, 1ST DOWN UTICA, NO PLAY. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Utica43 | Justin Becker rush for loss of 2 yards to the UTICA41 (Ryan Clifford;Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 2-12 | at Utica41 | Timeout Wilkes University, clock 02:14. |
| Utica | 2-12 | at Utica41 | Justin Becker rush for 13 yards to the WILKES46, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Tate Moore-Jaco). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes46 | Justin Becker rush for 1 yard to the WILKES45 (Walt Pabst). |
| Utica | 2-9 | at Wilkes45 | Timeout Wilkes University, clock 01:35. |
| Utica | 2-9 | at Wilkes45 | Justin Becker rush for 10 yards to the WILKES35, 1ST DOWN UTICA (Joe Chrismer;Kevin Gerhart). |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes35 | 2nd and 10. |
| Utica | 2-10 | at Wilkes35 | 1st and 10. |
| Utica | 1-10 | at Wilkes35 | TEAM rush for loss of 2 yards to the WILKES37. |
| Utica | 2-12 | at Wilkes37 | TEAM rush for no gain to the WILKES37. |
| Utica | 3-12 | at Wilkes37 | End of game, clock 00:00. |
| | | Drive: 8 plays, 32 yards, TOP 04:23 |
| | | FINAL SCORE |
| | | Utica College 24, Wilkes University 10 |